ACC schedule messes with success
Edward Cone
News & Record
11-21-04
They drew a mustache on the Mona Lisa. Gilded gold, fixed what wasn't broke, paved paradise and put up a parking lot. They went and changed the Atlantic Coast Conference basketball schedule.
The best college basketball league in the land starts the year with three teams (Wake Forest, Georgia Tech and Carolina) ranked among the top five in the national polls, and with three more teams in the top 20. An epic campaign could be in the offing.
What better time to mess with the tradition that helped make the conference great in the first place?
The very definition of an ACC regular season, yea unto generations, has been that every team played every other team twice a year, once at each school. Home and home. Tit for tat. White uniforms and road uniforms. No more. The league added new schools in order to become a football powerhouse, and squeezing the new schools into the basketball schedule stretched it out of shape.
Those three top-five teams, for example, meet only four times between them. Wake Forest does not visit Carolina, and Carolina does not visit Georgia Tech, the better to work Miami and Virginia Tech into the mix. NC State does not play at Duke, even though surviving a trip to Cameron Indoor Stadium is a rite of passage for every ACC team. And so on across the schedule, with Boston College added to the list next year.
The fans get a watered-down product and the teams face an uneven competitive landscape. And it's not just cranky old fans like me who still sing "Sail with the Pilot" in the shower and think of Georgia Tech as the new kids on the block who regard this as a problem.
"Your regular season champion -- there will always be a question mark," said Wake Forest head coach Skip Prosser to The Washington Post. "There will always be that cloud."
Expanding the conference into New England and South Florida for the sake of big-money football may turn out to be a sound investment by some measures, worth the cost to the ACC's hoop heritage. The ACC is an asset for its home city of Greensboro, and I'm rooting for it to succeed. Certainly it is exciting to have the glamorous Miami football program join the party (especially when you beat them the way UNC managed to do this year), and if the old ACC teams start frequenting major bowl games then a lot of people around here are going to be happy.
But college basketball as North Carolinians have known it and loved it is slipping away.
The game we grew up on has been under stress for a while. The most talented players hie to the pros, lowering the quality of play and tearing at the bonds of loyalty that fans feel for their teams. Meanwhile the winter months that once belonged to ACC basketball are crowded with more sports on more cable channels than ever before. There are too many games and too much Dick Vitale. And the ACC tournament is wandering ever further and more often from its ancestral home at the Greensboro Coliseum -- it will be held in North Carolina in only three of the next six years, and just twice in Greensboro.
Diluting the essential formula of conference play is a risky move. The ACC needs to be careful with its core asset, and its core audience, even as it tries to reach new markets. The league should at least figure out a way for its four North Carolina schools to play each other, home and home, every year. Those are the ancient rivalries that are fun even when all the teams aren't as good as they look to be this year.
Creating a better conference shouldn't mean uncreating what was great about the old one.
Edward Cone (www.edcone.com, efcone@mindspring.com) writes a column for the News & Record most Sundays.
Subscribe today | Electronic archives
